I agree with this post 100%. RCT2 was the best in the whole lot because it was very user-friendly by giving you everything in the game from the beginning with no unlockables, allowing the simple creation of new scenarios and rides, was fast even on slow computers (aside from the loading screens), the only problem are the game crashes and "loading Screens of Death" when loading custom graphics. But even without the customizability, RCT2 was just amazing.
Of course RCT3 did improve on the appearance and intelligence of the peeps, but aside from the addition of a true sandbox mode and many new rides (not to mention old rides with new track parts, "trains" and features, like the large 4x4 turn for Go Carts) it doesn't add anything new in my opinion. Going 3D, while it did help with editing in some cases, doesn't affect the gameplay whatsoever other than the game becoming slower and slower than RCT1 and 2.
What I think would be the best for RCT is if Chris Sawyer released a "Roller Coaster Tycoon 2 Deluxe" like what he did with RCT1, but add in most, if not all the enhancements from RCT3 that gave the series better performances and playability (none of that 3D slowing the game stuff! [Graphics =/= gameplay]), and of course, adds in the much needed compatibility with Windows 7.
Edited by Superjustinbros, 28 February 2012 - 09:09 PM.